participate


Sun Java System Directory Server - groupOfURLs behaves like auxiliary but schema says it's structural?!
<<   Back to Forum  |   Give us Feedback
This topic has 3 replies on 1 page.
klin
Posts:8
Registered: 01/11/06
groupOfURLs behaves like auxiliary but schema says it's structural?!   
Mar 13, 2003 12:23 PM

 
Schema gurus...

According to documentation the groupOfURLs object is "an auxiliary object class of groupOfUniqueNames or groupOfNames" -
http://docs.sun.com/source/816-6682-10/oc_dir25.htm#1303745

This is also evident by being able to create both static and dynamic group members in a single group entry using iPlanet Console 5.0. Subsequent searches on the object reveal its objectclass is top-groupofuniquenames-groupofurls with both uniqueMember and memberURL attributes.

Both the 5.0 00core.ldif file and an ldapsearch on "cn=schema" however reveal groupOfURLs is STRUCTURAL which I think means it cannot also be a (structural) groupOfUniqueName object.

objectclasses=( 2.16.840.1.113730.3.2.33 NAME 'groupOfURLs' DESC 'iPlanet defined objectclass' SUP top STRUCTURAL MUST cn MAY ( memberURL $ businessCategory $ description $ o $ ou $ owner $ seeAlso ) X-ORIGIN 'iPlanet Directory Server' )

Is the schema wrong (should be AUXILIARY instead of STRUCTURAL) or is the implementation wrong (members can be static XOR dynamic), or have I missed something?
 
Rich Megginson
Posts:558
Registered: 7/28/02
Re: groupOfURLs behaves like auxiliary but schema says it's structural?!   
Mar 13, 2003 12:42 PM (reply 1 of 3)  (In reply to original post )

 
The DS makes no distinction between STRUCTURAL and AUXILIARY.
 
klin
Posts:8
Registered: 01/11/06
Re: groupOfURLs behaves like auxiliary but schema says it's structural?!   
Mar 13, 2003 1:07 PM (reply 2 of 3)  (In reply to #1 )

 
The DS makes no distinction between STRUCTURAL and
AUXILIARY.

Thanks for the quick reply.

So it sounds to me like the 00core.ldif file (where some objectClasses are marked auxiliary) should reflect both the documentation (which explicitly says auxiliary) and actual behavior. This winds up being important if one is trying to implement an LDAP server supporting groupOfURLs.

Any idea where I can ask for an authoritative reply and possible correction to 00core.ldif (if in fact it is erroneous)?
 
Rich Megginson
Posts:558
Registered: 7/28/02
Re: groupOfURLs behaves like auxiliary but schema says it's structural?!   
Mar 13, 2003 2:34 PM (reply 3 of 3)  (In reply to #2 )

 
Just follow up with your support channel.
 
This topic has 3 replies on 1 page.
Back to Forum
 
Read the Developer Forums Code of Conduct

Click to email this message Email this Topic

Edit this Topic
  
 
 
Forums Statistics

About Sun forums
  • Oracle Forums is a large collection of user generated discussions. It is here to help you ask questions, find answers, and participate in discussions.

    Check out our guide on Getting started with Oracle Forums for a full walkthrough of how to best leverage the benefits of this community.

Powered by Jive Forums